E048 · Thinking, attention & executive function
Difficulty holding information in mind
What might be happening when a young person understands information when it is given but seems to lose part of it while trying to use it?
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Overview
Many everyday tasks require us to keep information temporarily available while doing something with it.
A young person might need to remember an instruction while finding equipment, hold the beginning of a sentence in mind while reading the end, retain numbers while calculating, or remember where they are within a sequence of actions.
This temporary mental workspace is often described as working memory.
When the amount of information exceeds a young person's available capacity, some of it may be lost before the task is finished.
From the outside this can look like inattention, carelessness, non-compliance or forgetting something that was “only just explained.”
Importantly, the young person may have listened and understood perfectly well at the point the information was given.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
What this might look like
A young person might:
- begin an instruction but forget later steps
- repeatedly ask what they were supposed to be doing
- lose their place during multi-step activities
- forget a question while trying to formulate the answer
- struggle to take notes while listening
- understand individual parts of an explanation but lose the overall thread
- forget what they intended to write while constructing a sentence
- lose track during mental arithmetic
- need instructions repeated
- appear to understand and then do something different
- find copying from a board unusually demanding
- struggle when required to listen and act simultaneously
- forget where they were after an interruption
- perform much better when information remains visible.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Developmental expression
At this stage
Early childhood
Many routines are externally structured by adults. Difficulties may appear during multi-step instructions, games, routines or activities requiring the child to remember what comes next.
Early childhood
Many routines are externally structured by adults. Difficulties may appear during multi-step instructions, games, routines or activities requiring the child to remember what comes next.
Middle childhood
Classroom learning increasingly relies on holding instructions, language, number information and task goals in mind while working independently.
Early adolescence
Longer explanations, note-taking, multiple teachers and increasingly complex learning create greater working-memory demands, while adults may simultaneously provide less external support.
Later adolescence
Independent study, employment tasks, planning and complex instructions require young people to manage information across increasingly demanding contexts.
Choose each stage to see how the presentation and surrounding expectations may change over time.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Strengths and differences
Difficulty holding information temporarily does not imply difficulty with long-term knowledge or understanding.
A young person may:
- have excellent long-term memory
- possess extensive knowledge about areas of interest
- reason very effectively when information is visible
- produce sophisticated ideas
- recognise information they could not recall unaided
- perform substantially better when cognitive load is reduced.
This difference matters. Repeating information more loudly or assuming the young person was not listening may completely miss the problem.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Top tips for support
- Keep important information visible.
- Reduce the number of instructions given at once.
- Break sequences into manageable steps.
- Ask the young person to show what they are going to do rather than repeatedly testing whether they remembered every word.
- Use checklists, diagrams, examples and written prompts.
- Avoid requiring simultaneous listening, remembering and recording where possible.
- Give access to reference materials rather than treating remembering as the learning objective when it is not.
- Reduce unnecessary verbal load.
- Re-establish the task after interruptions.
- Encourage external memory supports as legitimate tools.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Things needing careful planning
Adults should distinguish between:
remembering information over time and holding information temporarily while using it.
A young person can have strong long-term memory while struggling significantly with working-memory demands.
Performance also varies according to distraction, stress, fatigue, familiarity, language demands and the complexity of the information. Working memory should therefore not be treated as a fixed everyday capacity that looks identical across contexts.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Practical support principles
A central Phoenix principle here is:
If information does not need to be held in the young person's head, consider putting it into the environment.
Support can include:
- written instructions
- visual sequences
- task cards
- worked examples
- number lines and reference materials
- checklists
- planners
- visible vocabulary
- reduced instruction length
- repeating or rephrasing information without judgement
- pausing between steps
- routines that reduce the amount that must be remembered
- explicit teaching in the use of external memory systems.
From understanding to support
Phoenix Atlas connections
Often useful
- visual supports
- executive-function scaffolding
- cognitive-load reduction
- task chunking
- environmental adaptation
Worth considering
- metacognitive strategies
- memory strategies
- assistive technology
- specialist assessment where difficulties significantly affect learning.
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Evidence and cautions
Working memory has a substantial research literature and is closely connected with classroom learning because many educational activities require information to be stored temporarily while other cognitive operations occur. (1)
However, there is an important intervention caution. Evidence for computerised working-memory training has historically shown limited transfer to sustained improvements in everyday classroom functioning or academic attainment. This argues for caution about trying to “train the deficit” when environmental scaffolding may directly reduce unnecessary working-memory demands. (2)
Research on classroom interaction also indicates that executive functioning develops within environmental and relational contexts rather than functioning independently of them. (1)
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Public evidence sources
Phoenix Encyclopaedia
Possible explanatory lenses
Relevant possibilities include:
- working-memory capacity
- attention
- language processing
- executive functioning
- learning difficulties
- cognitive load
- anxiety
- fatigue or sleep
- sensory distraction
- unfamiliarity with the task
- environmental complexity.
About this entry’s source
Open Beta · read the evidence notes and limitations
Source status describes the underlying material. The current site edition is Open Beta; the evidence notes and limitations remain part of the entry.
Phoenix Atlas · Open Beta
Explore connected approaches
These Atlas entries link to this topic for a specific reading purpose. Follow the connection and its limits in the entry; it is not an automatic intervention recommendation.
validation is being completed by subject matter experts